THE INKY WAY : DAILY HERALD
In May 1930 Leatherland resigned from his job with the
Labour Party Press and Publicity Department. He joined the editorial staff of the Daily Herald as a political
sub-editor on a weekly salary of fourteen pounds and fourteen shillings a week.
The Daily Herald was different from other Fleet Street daily newspapers. It had no commercial aims and loyally supported the Labour Party. The Daily Herald is largely forgotten these days. This is
probably because the paper closed down in 1964 and turned into The Sun.
The Herald also stood apart from the rest of
Fleet Street. It was geographically separate being based on the junction of
Endell Street and Long Acre in Covent Garden. Its political stance was left
wing at a time when most of the press was centre right. This is how its
historian, Huw Richards, describes the paper :
“From its first issue, on 15 April 1912, to its last, on 14
September 1964, the Herald was a challenge to the norms and assumptions of the
British press. The rhetoric of the national press proclaims that it is an
industry characterised by individualism and diversity. In practice, driven by
competitive pressures and fear of failure, it tends to conformity and
convergence, ever vulnerable to the latest gimmick, craze or means of sales
promotion for fear of losing a march on rivals. The Daily Herald was different.
Where other Fleet Street papers were essentially commercial in motivation, the
Herald was overtly political. Fleet Street's ideology was capitalist, but the
Herald espoused anti-capitalism. Other papers were created and owned by wealthy
proprietors - the Herald was first the creation of part of the labour movement
and then the property of the whole of it.”
Much of my summary of the Daily Herald's history is based on Huw Richards' excellent book "The Bloody Circus : The Daily Herald and the
Left" (Pluto Press, 1997).
History of the Daily Herald
The Daily Herald was launched in 1912. Edited by George Lansbury, it struggled in
its early years reverting to a weekly edition during World War One when it took
a pacifist line campaigning against conscription and supporting conscientious
objectors. Beset by financial difficulties, the Herald came under the control
of the Labour Party and the Trades Union Congress in 1922 becoming the TUC’s
official organ. Prestigious journalists such as Douglas (GDH) Cole joined the
paper under the editorship of Hamilton Fyffe (1922 - 1926).
William Mellor became its Editor in 1926. He had been Deputy
Editor since 1922 and he had worked on the Herald since 1913. He was imprisoned
as a conscientious objector during World War One. He was a founder member of
the Communist Party of Great Britain in the early 1920s. Many years after his
death in 1942, it was revealed that he had a long running affair with Barbara
Betts, who was a journalist on the socialist Tribune magazine and who later became
Labour minister, Barbara Castle.
Huw Richards describes Mellor as a “formidable character”,
quoting Margaret Cole who said that he was a powerful personality whose
emotions were easily aroused and prone to bullying. Michael Foot worked with
him on Tribune in the late 1930s and remembered him as a shouting editor and
endearing ogre. Mellor was sacked as Editor in 1930 but he would have been
Leatherland’s first Editor for a year or so.
Although the Daily Herald was booming during the first half
of the 1930s, the Labour Party had a troubled time. The 1931 General Election
saw a landslide election victory for the National Government which had been
formed two months previously after the collapse of the second Labour
government. The parties forming the National Government won 67% of the votes
and 554 seats out of 615. The bulk of its support came from the Conservative Party who won 470 seats. The
Labour Party suffered its greatest defeat, losing four out of every five seats
compared with the previous election, including the seat of its leader, Arthur
Henderson.
The Daily Herald During the 1930s
In 1930 the TUC sold a 51 per cent share of the Herald to publishing company, Odhams Press. Will
Stevenson, a Welsh ex-miner, became the new Editor. Attempts were made to make
the paper more mainstream with big promotion campaigns. In 1930 Odhams acquired
premises in Manchester to print a northern edition of the paper. Much work was done to increase circulation,
like offering sets of books, including a 16 volume set of Charles Dickens
books, at low prices to readers of the paper. These were a great success. By 1933 the Daily Herald briefly became the
world's best-selling daily newspaper, with certified net sales of two million
copies a day.
Odhams
In 1933, W.J.B. Odhams resigned as Chairman of Odhams, and
Julian Elias became Chairman and Managing Director. By 1935, Odhams were printers of around sixty
newspapers and employed over ten thousand people.
Odhams Press was originally a newspaper publisher founded in
the nineteenth century. In 1892, William Odhams sold the business to his sons,
but two years later they set up a separate business, Odhams Brothers Ltd. in
Hart Street (later Floral Street) in Covent Garden. In 1898, the company became Odhams Ltd, and in 1920 it became known as Odhams Press
and merged with John Bull magazine. Later, Odhams expanded into book publishing.
Julius Salter Elias, who later became Lord Southwood, was a
major figure in Odhams and Daily Herald history. He joined the company as a
clerk in 1894 and rose to become a director by 1898. Elias oversaw an enormous expansion of the
business’ activities and premises. In
1905 Odhams moved into premises in Long Acre, Covent Garden where it later
occupied buildings on both sides of the street. Under Elias’ leadership, Odhams
not only took on the printing of newspapers, and absorbed other printing
establishments, but the company also became publishers of books.
Following Odhams’ acquisition of a majority holding in the
Herald, the paper was revitalised. Huw Richards describes the new format of the
paper as “dramatically different to look at, not only to its low cost
predecessor, but to anything seen previously in Britain”. He says that the
Herald became a design innovator and the first popular paper to use layout to
create a distinct visual identity. The Herald was able to tap into Odhams’ expertise as printers. Its content was also
invigorated. Richards quotes the editor, Mellor, who told the Labour Magazine
that “Political news … must take its place as news and not just sprawl over the
paper covering every page and obtruding into every nook and cranny”. Politics
and industry continued to have dedicated pages but, unlike the old Herald, they
were two pages out of twenty – the old paper’s political content took up around
half of the whole paper. There were more
popular features, and better coverage of music, arts, radio, business and
finance.
In 1929 there was a massive drive to achieve these aims. The size of the paper was doubled from ten to twenty pages; rallies and events promoting the new Herald were held across the country; members of the Labour Party were recruited to promote the paper, and a prize incentive scheme was implemented where premium cameras and free gifts were given away on purchase of the paper. These initiatives resulted in a steep increase in the Herald's circulation from 250,000 to a million.
This trend continued until, in 1933, the Herald briefly became the best selling popular daily newspaper in the world, with sales of 2 million. The sharp increase in circulation spurred the Herald's competitors into action and the more conservative Beaverbrook owned newspapers (e.g. the Daily Express) began to solicit support for their publications. A circulation war began, and the Herald's circulation declined. By February 1932 the Herald’s daily circulation figures
reached 1.5 million overtaking the News Chronicle. Later that year it overtook
the Mail which had long been the market leader, and by 1933 it had overtaken
the circulation figures of the Express. From 1933 to 1936 the Herald was the
best selling British newspaper, indeed it claimed the world’s largest daily net
newspaper sales. A survey in 1934 showed the Herald to be the most widely read
newspapers in many regions, including
Greater London, the South East, the West Midlands and the North West.
Huw Richards reports Francis Williams’ belief that Elias
begrudged all editorial expenditure except on big name writers who could be
used for promotional purposes. The features writer HV Morton and the
“cantankerously brilliant Hannen Swaffer” – described by Richards as the Pope
of Fleet Street – both received salaries of £5,000 a year. But elsewhere there
was a deep reluctance of Odhams to spend. Richards quotes Arthur Webb, a senior
Odhams executive during the 1930s, who said that Odhams strived to economise in the editorial
department. He cites Tom Driberg who was on the Express in the 1930s and who
recalled that the Herald was “notorious for parsimony over expenses”. In July 1931 the Herald NUJ Chapel was
complaining about dismissals and salary cuts. In June 1932 a list of staff
changes showed that there had been sixteen sackings among the fifty eight
editorial staff who had been on the paper two years earlier. Richards says that
survivors of the old 1920s Herald seem to have been particularly vulnerable to
economy cuts. In some cases the list gave personal reasons for sackings :
Broddzky (indiscipline) and Dawson (dereliction of duty).
Francis Williams told the Royal Commission on the Press in
1947 that John Dunbar, Odhams Editor-in-Chief, had the final say on decisions involving expenditure, rather than
the Herald Editor so that he could , if he wished, curtail the sending of
foreign correspondents to certain places on financial rather than policy
grounds. The Herald was not well off in terms of foreign correspondents,
despite that the fact that during the 1930s what was happening in the outside
word was of deep concern to Britain. Arthur Webb, who was Night Editor,
recalled that the Herald lacked any staff correspondents in Germany, Italy and
the USA throughout the crisis years of the 1930s. An NUJ inquiry of 1938 made criticisms of the Herald’s “inhibitions,
prohibitions, taboos, conflicting instructions and steam rollering” which had
destroyed initiative and reduced the staff to “mass-production units”.
Despite these problems the Herald remained politically
distinctive. A 1936 analysis showed that the paper had a higher proportion
(33%) of public affairs news and political / social / economic / industrial
features than any of its popular rivals and the more heavyweight Daily Telegraph. The Herald
remained invariably supportive of the Labour Party or TUC party lines of the
day. Hannen Swaffer was critical of the Herald’s frequent neglect of personality and human interest in its political coverage.
Some of the highlights of Herald content during the 1930s as
portrayed by Huw Richards were journalist Richie Calder’s coverage of the Jarrow marches, Swaffer’s
columns which “ranger widely and eloquently”, and the ‘bought in star’ Francis
Williams appointed as City Editor whose column aimed to link finance with
political and economic policy.
At the beginning of 1937 Frances Williams took over as Daily
Herald Editor and served in this post for four years. Later he became
Controller of Press Censorship and News at the Ministry of Information during
the Second World War, Clement Attlee’s Press Secretary, and a Labour life peer.
In the late 1920s the Herald was under much financial
pressure. In September 1927 it had only four general reporters, less than half
the total of any other national newspaper. In early 1928 its total editorial
staff was 44, compared with 68 on the
Chronicle. An Editor’s Report by William Mellor, quoted by Huw Richards, shows the pressure the paper was under in March 1928, it also helps to
illustrate sub-editors’ working patterns.
Mellor's Letter to Leatherland offering him the job of Daily Herald Sub-Editor 1930
“The sub-editorial staff consisted of ten. The chief
sub-editor was taking his fortnightly day off ; the industrial sub-editor had a
day owing to him in consequence of the previous illness of the industrial
editor : and one man was away sick. These ten had to work a seven hour day
(with their time off) beginning at 12 o’clock and finishing at 1 am (in actual
fact they finish at 1.30am). Two men finished their day when the First Edition
went through, one man finished at 9pm, four men finished at 10pm, one make-up
man finished when the Second Edition went through, leaving three men for the
Third Edition, and the Parliamentary sub who worked overtime. That night the whole paper had to be remade on the Second
Edition, owing to the course which the Zinoviev debate took, and on the Third
Edition extensive changes were necessary. The result was that on the Third
Edition the paper was terribly understaffed, and it was necessary for myself
and the Night Editor to take a very active, but not purely editorial part in the making of the Second and Third
editions.”
Not only does this show the pressures on editorial staff,
but it reminds us that a daily newspaper went through several editions as news
broke.
The Role of a Political Sub-Editor
Leatherland’s first job on the Daily Herald was as a
political sub-editor. A sub-editor’s job is to read the articles written by
journalists and knock them into shape for the paper. The role was described in
the Inky Way Annual as having “power without glory”. In the 1930s most national daily newspapers had around
twenty sub-editors headed by a Chief sub-editor. Subs (as they were known) had
to be experts in conciseness. They controlled the length and content of
journalists’ stories. They knew how much space there would be in the paper for
each story, and they would often write the headlines. They were responsible for
ensuring that the story was factually correct, the grammar and spelling was
accurate, and that it was tailored to the paper’s house style, tone and target
audience.
Sub-editing was a demanding job. It required constant
attention to detail in a fast-paced working environment. The following modern
job description of a sub-editor’s role is probably just as relevant to the
1930s :
- Editing
the copy written by reporters or features writers to remove spelling mistakes
and grammatical errors
- Rewriting
material so that it flows or reads better and adheres to the paper’s house
style
- Ensuring
that a story fits a particular word count by cutting or expanding material as
necessary
- Writing
headlines that capture the essence of the story or are clever or amusing
- Writing
‘stand-firsts’ or 'sells' (a brief introduction which sums up the story
underneath the headline)
- Liaising
with reporters, journalists and editors
- Checking
facts and stories to ensure they are accurate and adhere to copyright laws, and
that they are not libellous or contrary to the paper’s policy
- Cropping
photos and deciding where to use them for best effect and writing picture
captions
- Proofreading
complete pages produced by other sub-editors
- Working
to a page plan to ensure that the right stories appear in the correct place on
each page
- Laying
out pages and sometimes playing a part in page design
Sub-editors had to be flexible working late to meet
deadlines if necessary. Working on a
national daily newspaper often involved unsocial hours with early or late
shifts. Work cycles built up to a
frenetic peak just before the paper was due to go to press. But sub-editors
were often resented by journalists whose copy might be ruthlessly pruned to
meet the paper’s needs.
Sub-editors could be powerful figures. As Huw Richards
explains : “Newspapers are complex, sensitive mechanisms subject to an
immense range of influences and pressures. They are put together in a hurry.
Editors are important but they cannot write to edit every item that appears.
Much rests on decisions taken by other members of staff – writers, sub-editors,
picture editors and others – under the pressure of deadlines. Because of these pressures and the dependence
of newspapers on unpredictable external events for their material, much of what
appears is fortuitous. It would be rash
to make much of a run of the mill news story appearing at the bottom of page
five. It may reflect some crucial
political subtext. But it is far more
likely that it was selected at the last moment from a mass of agency copy by a
sub-editor desperate for something the right length".
The Inky Way Annual said that national daily newspapers had
twenty or more sub-editors headed by a Chief Sub-Editor. But the 1928 memo
showed the Herald only had ten sub-editorial staff who were working on seven
hour shifts between 12 noon and 1.30 am.
By 1937 Leatherland was ‘Father’ of the Daily Herald
National Union of Journalists (NUJ) editorial ‘chapel’. The chapel held
meetings and negotiated with management on behalf of members. The Father of the chapel was a shop steward representing
union members. The name originates from the early history of printing in
Britain when printing offices were controlled by churches.
In 1969 during a House of Lords debate on the Theft Bill
where the offence of criminal deception was being discussed, Leatherland told
the following story :
“Forty years ago, when I was a young sub-editor with one of
our national Sunday papers…..It was a quarter to twelve on a Saturday night; we
had just put one edition to bed, and another was due in a quarter of an hour. I
was sitting drinking the proverbial tea with the editor when in came a message: There's a man outside with a fine story. The editor said: Charles, go and see what it is. I went and saw the man. He was an Irishman wearing tattered
clothes, and he produced a letter from his parish priest in Ireland saying that
his poor old aunt had died and left him £50,000. So I immediately sat down at the typewriter
and created a wonderful romantic story of this poor, unemployed man roaming
half-starved about London suddenly becoming possessed of a fortune of £50,000. I showed it to the editor. He said That's fine . Don't you think we ought to ring up the priest? He said,;No; we haven't time. So it went on the front page in the next
edition. Less than three-quarters of an hour later we had the police
telephoning us from Piccadilly Circus saying that this man had been showing a
cutting from that morning's paper saying that he had come into £50,000, and had
already managed to borrow two lots of £10 from unsuspecting people.
As a Political Sub-Editor Leatherland’s name did not appear in print as he did not pen his own stories, although a search in the British Newspaper Archive shows that he wrote one or two articles in the late 1930s.
In May 1938 Leatherland was promoted to Assistant News
Editor on a salary of seventeen guineas a week plus two guineas weekly
expenses.
Freelance Journalism
Leatherland also worked as a freelance journalist from time
to time. His daughter, Irene, told me that he used to rent a tiny studio room
in Bloomsbury on Friday evenings in order to write articles for weekend
newspapers and periodicals. Leatherland admitted to me that he did this
surreptitiously because the Daily Herald would not have been pleased if they
discovered he was writing for other newspapers. Irene told that he sometimes
wrote under the pseudonym of Charles Morgan (Morgan was his wife’s
maiden name) so that his employers at the Daily Herald would not find out that
he was also writing for rival papers, although I have not yet found evidence of this.
The extent of his freelance activities is not known,
although his handwritten note on the above copy in his archives suggests that
he wrote an anonymous weekly political gossip column in the Weekly Dispatch
newspaper in the late 1920s and early 1930s. The Sunday Dispatch was a
prominent newspaper, published between 1801 and 1961 when it merged with the Sunday Express. It was called<the Weekly Dispatch until 1928 when it became the Sunday Dispatch. At
one point it became the biggest selling Sunday newspaper in Britain.
Some of the publications Leatherland wrote for were published by Odhams Press such the weekly magazines The Passing Show and John
Bull.
The Inky Way
The life of a News Editor was described by Leatherland
himself in a feature he wrote for the Inky Way Annual (1947-48), a book which
was intended to explain the world of newspapers to the general public. Here is his article “A Day in the Life of a
News Editor”.
Working Hours
In a speech to the House of Lords in 1966 on the Sunday
Entertainments Bill, Leatherland made the following observations on his working hours as Daily Herald Assistant Editor :
"As for the supposed inconvenience to any individual who has
to work on Sundays, I think the effect of this can be exaggerated. For many
years as a newspaper editorial executive I had to work nearly every Sunday in
the year. It is true that I had a compensatory day off later in the week, and I
feel that this point ought to be embodied in any Bill which attempts to deal
with Sunday observance in the future. In actual fact, I used to get Tuesdays
off, and Tuesday was the day when the local foxhounds hunted in my
neighbourhood, so that a good time was had by all. Then on Wednesday morning,
perhaps a little bruised, but sore and satisfied, I was able to go back to my
desk and face with equanimity anything that happened to come along. I think the
objection that this would create Sunday work can be overdone. But I should like
to insist, as I said, that there should be a compensatory day off and, in any
case, that no person should be sacked for refusing to work seven days a week".
Daily Herald Journalists and Editorial Staff
The Herald had a number of well-known journalists during its
lifetime. They included :
William
Ewer was Daily Herald diplomatic correspondent from the 1920s to the 1950s. He was s later revealed to have been an active and well-connected Soviet agent in
the 1920s well known to MI5 who kept him under surveillance.
Hannen
Swaffer was a Daily Herald journalist and drama critic described by Huw Richards as
“cantankerously brilliant”.
Ritchie
Calder was a Scottish socialist author, journalist and academic.
H.V.
Morton was a journalist, travel and features writer who worked on the Herald
between 1931 and 1942.
Francis
Williams worked on Lancashire papers before becoming a financial
journalist on the Evening Standard. He became City Editor of the Daily Herald
and then its Editor between 1936 and 1940. In 1941 Williams became Controller
of Press Censorship and News at the Ministry of Information. After the war he
was an adviser to Labour PM Clement Attlee. He became a Life Peer in 1962.
Maurice
Webb was a Herald political reporter in the 1930s who also worked as Labour Party
propaganda officer and later became a Labour MP and Minister of Food
Will
Dyson was an Australian political cartoonist who contributed to the Herald from the
outset until his death in 1938.
Douglas
Jay was an economic journalist on the Herald from 1937 to 1941. He later became a
Labour MP and Minister.
Letter from Leatherland as Daily Herald Assistant Editor to Morgan Phillips, Labour Party General Secretary (March 1958) - from Labour Party Archives
Local Politics
It is not clear whether Leatherland was active in local
politics during the 1930s, although it seems likely that he was. Dunton was in
the former Parliamentary constituency of South East Essex and had a Conservative MP, Henry Raikes, from 1931 to
1945. The local council was Billericay Urban District Council whose Chairman
was a Conservative from 1934 to 1946. From 1934 Dunton had a parish council but in 1937 it became part of Billericay
parish council.
Invitation and Visiting Cards
Although Leatherland was only a sub-editor and later an
assistant news editor, some ides of the circles within which he mixed can be
gained from some of his invitation cards.
It is not clear why Leatherland was invited to a reception
at the USSR (Union of Soviet Socialist Republics) Embassy in Kensington Palace
Gardens. This invitation card says that it was being held to bid farewell to
Monsieur and Madame Bogonoff. By the end of the 1920s the USSR was led by Stalin who had
established totalitarian rule. But from the early 1930s there was closer
cooperation between the West and the USSR. For example from 1932 to 1934, the Soviet Union participated in the
World Disarmament Conference and in 1933, the USA’s newly elected President
Roosevelt formally recognized Stalin's Communist government, restored
diplomatic relations, and negotiated a new trade agreement between the two
nations. So perhaps it was not unusual for a journalist on the leftwing Herald
to receive such an invitation. And of course it is not known whether he
actually attended the reception.
Sidney Webb was a socialist, economist, and reformer who
helped to found the London School of Economics. Along with his wife Beatrice
Webb, he helped to turn the Fabian Society into the pre-eminent
political-intellectual society of England during the early decades of the
twentieth century. He was the author of the Labour Party’s notorious Clause IV.
He became a Labour MP in 1922 and later became a Labour Peer. At the time of this invitation card, he was
Colonial Secretary although he stood down when the Labour Government lost power
nine months later.
Daily Herald's Decline
Throughout this period, and for many years afterwards, the Herald continued to espouse Labour policies, defined by the Labour Party and at TUC conferences. However, whilst its appeal had broadened, Odhams Press felt that the political ties were hampering its growth. Nevertheless, the increasingly uneasy TUC - Odhams relationship managed to last for about thirty years until finally, in 1960, faced with diminishing sales and the loss of advertising revenue, Odhams persuaded the TUC to relinquish their shares. But the paper's slide had become irreversible and, in March 1961, Mirror Group Newspapers (MGN\IPC) took over the paper and Odhams publishing.
The company began a massive drive to revive the ailing Herald. After an initial period of assessment, MGN/IPC decided to enliven the image of the paper in order to broaden its appeal. In September 1964 the paper was relaunched as The Sun. Despite this change of image, the paper’s format remained stale and uninspiring. After an initial upsurge in circulation, sales again declined. MGN/IPC cut their losses and in 1969 sold the Sun to Rupert Murdoch's News International, whereupon its content and message completely altered.
Retirement from Daily Herald
In April 1963 Leatherland celebrated his 65th birthday. At
the same time he retired from the Daily Herald where he had worked for thirty
three years. He received a pension of £1,067 per annum under the Odhams
Superannuation Scheme, which eventually became a Reed International pension due
to later company takeovers. Leatherland once commented that it was a relatively
poor pension as the Odhams Scheme did not became a proper contributory one
until 1961 although it did take some account of his length of In 1964 he was called back to
head The Sun’s election night team.